What if the very backbone of your industrial operation - the fibre optics connecting your most critical assets - is also its most exposed and forgotten attack surface?


Cybersecurity in automation

The Silent Crisis in Your Control Network:
Securing the Industrial Fibre Backbone Everyone Forgets

Why Your Most Expensive Machinery is Only as Reliable as Its Weakest Network Link

For decades, the conversation around industrial networks has been dominated by one metric: bandwidth. But on the factory floor, in the electrical substation, or along the railway line, raw speed is a hollow victory if a single, mistimed data packet can halt production, trigger a safety shutdown, or endanger lives.

The true benchmark of industrial networking is not speed, but certainty. It’s the guarantee that a critical control signal will arrive at its destination not just quickly, but precisely on time, every time. This is the world of deterministic networking, and fibre optics are its indispensable physical backbone.

This guide moves beyond the simplistic sales pitches to explore the core engineering principles that separate a functional fibre network from a resilient, secure, and deterministic industrial nervous system. We will dismantle dangerous myths, expose hidden vulnerabilities, and detail the architectures and technologies - from Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) to Parallel Redundancy Protocol (PRP) - that define modern operational technology (OT).

Cybersecurity Matters

Beyond Bandwidth: Why Determinism, Not Speed, Defines Industrial Success

In the IT world, network performance is measured in megabytes per second and latency is an inconvenience. In the OT world, latency variance - known as jitter - is the enemy. A network can have immense bandwidth, but if jitter is uncontrolled, it destabilizes the finely tuned control loops that govern machinery, robots, and processes.

Consider the consequences of indeterminism:
  • A robotic welder on an automotive line receiving a "fire" command a few milliseconds late, resulting in a faulty weld.
  • A variable frequency drive (VFD) in a pumping station receiving inconsistent speed commands, causing harmful cavitation and mechanical stress.
  • A safety instrumented system (SIS) in a chemical plant experiencing a delayed "emergency stop" signal due to network congestion.

These are not failures of speed, but failures of predictability.

The Engine of Determinism: Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN)

TSN is a set of IEEE standards that transforms standard Ethernet into a deterministic, time-aware network. It acts like a traffic management system for your data, creating scheduled "green light" windows for time-critical traffic while allowing best-effort data (like file transfers or video streams) to use the remaining capacity.

How TSN and Fibre Optics Create a Synchronized System:
  1. Time Synchronization (IEEE 802.1AS-Rev): Every switch, controller, and device on the network is synchronized to a common clock, often with microsecond or nanosecond precision.
  2. Scheduled Traffic (IEEE 802.1Qbv): Critical control messages are assigned to specific, recurring time slots in the network cycle. These messages bypass any queued traffic, guaranteeing their passage.
  3. Frame Pre-emption (IEEE 802.1Qbu): A large, non-critical frame can be interrupted to let a small, critical frame pass through immediately, then resume transmission. This drastically reduces latency for urgent commands.

Fibre optics are the ideal physical medium for TSN. Their inherent immunity to electromagnetic interference (EMI) ensures that the precise timing of these scheduled packets is not corrupted by electrical noise from motors, drives, or power lines. The consistent signal propagation in fibre eliminates the variable latency that can occur in copper cables under different environmental conditions.

Ultimately, achieving determinism is an end-to-end engineering challenge. It requires every component - from Westermo and Welotec switches managing the TSN queues to ProSoft and ATOP gateways providing precise protocol translation - to be selected and configured with timing guarantees in mind. The goal isn't more bandwidth; it's unwavering predictability that keeps industrial systems synchronized, safe, and efficient.

Cybersecurity Matters

The “Inherently Secure” Myth: Real Threats to Industrial Fibre

A pervasive and dangerous assumption plagues industrial security: "Our network is on fibre, so it can't be tapped." This misconception breeds complacency, leaving critical control networks exposed to sophisticated physical-layer attacks.

While it's true that fibre does not radiate electromagnetic signals like copper, making it immune to passive eavesdropping, it is far from impervious. The physical cable itself, and the devices that connect to it, present a tangible attack surface.

The Real Threats at the Optical Layer

  • Optical Tapping: Using a microscopic bend in the fibre, an attacker can extract a portion of the light signal without breaking the core. Advanced methods can be virtually undetectable without specialized monitoring equipment.
  • Light Injection: An attacker can splice into the fibre or exploit an accessible patch panel to inject malicious commands or data directly into the light stream, bypassing all traditional firewall and intrusion detection systems.
  • Rogue Transceivers & Media Converters: These small, often unmanaged devices can be pre-programmed with malicious firmware. When installed, they can create hidden backdoors, manipulate data in transit, or act as an unauthorized bridge between network segments.

These threats are particularly insidious because they operate below the level of IP packets. They target the physical and data link layers, where conventional IT cybersecurity tools have no visibility.

Building a Demonstrably Secure Fibre Backbone

True fibre security requires a layered defence strategy that moves from presumption to proof:

  1. Physical Security & Control: The first line of defence. Secure conduits, locked cabinets, and tamper-evident seals on patch panels are non-negotiable.
  2. Continuous Optical Monitoring: Using Optical Time-Domain Reflectometry (OTDR) and continuous power-level analysis to establish a "baseline" for each fibre link. Any deviation - a signal loss indicating a bend, or a reflection indicating a new splice - can trigger an immediate alert.
  3. Hardware Integrity: Sourcing all transceivers, media converters, and switches from trusted, industrial-grade suppliers like ATOP and Westermo to prevent counterfeit or tampered hardware from entering the ecosystem.
  4. Link-Layer Encryption: Implementing MACsec (IEEE 802.1AE) provides encryption and integrity checking at the Ethernet frame level, securing data even against successful physical taps.

By combining these measures, fibre transitions from a presumed security asset into a demonstrably secure industrial backbone.

Cybersecurity Matters

The Hidden Attack Surface: Media Converters, Patch Panels & Unmanaged Switches

Industrial networks are often a complex tapestry of modern managed switches and legacy, simple devices. It is these simple devices - unmanaged media converters, patch panels, and switches - that frequently form the most vulnerable, yet overlooked, attack surface.

They are the "plumbing" of the network: essential, ubiquitous, and considered too basic to be a threat. This perceived innocence is what makes them so dangerous. They bridge critical control segments yet typically offer no authentication, no logging, no segmentation, and no security features.

How Simple Devices Create Massive Risk

  • The Segmentation Collapse: An unmanaged media converter can transparently bridge a secure, air-gapped control network with a less secure office network, completely undoing carefully planned network architecture.
  • The Silent Listeners: Unmanaged switches often have no port security. An attacker can simply plug into any unused port and listen to all broadcast traffic, or use Address Resolution Protocol (ARP) poisoning to intercept unicast traffic.
  • The Opaque Maze: Unlabelled or poorly documented patch panels make it impossible to trace connections during an incident response, allowing malicious connections to remain hidden.

When you compound these issues with default credentials on managed devices, outdated firmware, or counterfeit components, this foundational infrastructure becomes a silent enabler of compromise.

Hardening the Connectivity Layer

Securing these components delivers one of the highest returns on investment for your overall cybersecurity posture.

  • Eliminate Unmanaged Critical Links: Replace unmanaged media converters and switches in critical paths with managed, industrial-grade devices from vendors like Westermo, ATOP, and FlexDSL. This introduces access control lists (ACLs), VLANs, and port security.
  • Implement Strict Physical Inventory: Label every port, every patch cable, and every device. Maintain accurate and up-to-date network diagrams.
  • Enable Security Features: On managed devices, disable unused ports, implement MAC address whitelisting, and ensure firmware is regularly updated.

By hardening this hidden layer, you transform the weakest parts of your network into its most defensible assets.

AI-Powered Fibre Health Monitoring: Predicting Failures & Detecting Breaches

The reliability of your entire industrial operation can depend on the integrity of a single, fragile strand of glass. Traditional monitoring is binary: the link is either "up" or "down." It only alerts you when it's already too late, during a costly outage.

AI-driven monitoring transforms this reactive approach into a predictive and proactive intelligence system. By continuously analysing optical performance data in real-time, machine learning algorithms can detect minute changes that are invisible to human operators or threshold-based systems.

From Reactive to Predictive Intelligence

  1. Establishing an Optical Fingerprint: The AI learns the unique "personality" of each fibre link, understanding its normal baseline for attenuation, reflectance, and bit error rates (BER) under different conditions (e.g., day/night temperature cycles).
  2. Predicting Physical Failures: The system can recognize the gradual increase in signal loss that precedes a fibre break due to stress, or the growing reflectance from a degrading splice. This allows maintenance to be scheduled weeks in advance, preventing unplanned downtime.
  3. Detecting Security Breaches: Anomaly detection algorithms are trained to identify the distinctive optical signatures of physical-layer attacks. A subtle, intermittent bend from a clamp-on tap, or a new, unauthorized splice for signal injection, will create a deviation from the established fingerprint, triggering a security alert.

Vendors like Welotec, Westermo, and ProSoft are now integrating edge-enabled AI capabilities directly into their industrial networking equipment. This allows for local processing of data, ensuring real-time response and operational resilience even if the connection to a central cloud is lost.

The result is a self-monitoring fibre infrastructure that not only forecasts its own maintenance needs but also stands guard against physical intrusion.

Encryption vs. Determinism: Securing Fibre Without Breaking Real-Time Control

A fundamental conflict has long existed in industrial networking: the need for cybersecurity versus the need for deterministic performance. Engineers rightly fear that adding encryption could introduce the very latency and jitter that will break their real-time control loops.

In a motion control system or a power grid protection relay, processing delays of even a few milliseconds from software-based encryption can be catastrophic. This perceived trade-off has left many critical fibre networks running in the clear, vulnerable to data manipulation and interception.

Cybersecurity Matters

Resolving the Conflict with Modern Solutions

The solution lies in using the right type of encryption, implemented in the right way:

  • MACsec (Media Access Control Security): This IEEE standard (802.1AE) provides encryption and integrity at the data link layer (Layer 2). Unlike IPsec (Layer 3), which requires routing and can add variable latency, MACsec secures traffic as it enters and exits the Ethernet port, preserving microsecond-level timing.
  • Hardware Acceleration: Purpose-built industrial switches from manufacturers like Westermo and ATOP integrate hardware-accelerated encryption engines. These dedicated chips offload the cryptographic processing from the main CPU, ensuring that encryption and decryption happen at wire speed with negligible latency and no jitter.

This approach allows for a "secure by design" deterministic network. Control traffic can be encrypted without compromising the scheduled delivery guarantees of TSN.

A Layered, Risk-Based Strategy

Not all data is equally critical. A balanced security policy might involve:

  • Maximum Protection: Applying MACsec to all inter-switch links (the network fabric) and for all critical controller-to-device communication.
  • Selective Encryption: For less time-sensitive sensor data, simpler encryption methods may be sufficient.

By strategically applying hardware-accelerated, layer-2 encryption, engineers can finally achieve both security and determinism, enabling safe and reliable IT/OT convergence.

Designing Zero-Recovery Fibre Rings: PRP, HSR & RSTP for Sub-10ms Failover

In critical infrastructure, network redundancy isn't a feature - it's a requirement for safety and availability. However, traditional redundancy protocols like Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) have recovery times measured in seconds, an eternity for automated systems. A sub-second network outage can cause a manufacturing cell to fault, a generator to trip, or a conveyor system to jam.

The new standard is zero-recovery networking, where redundancy is active and simultaneous, ensuring that a single fault has no perceptible impact on control systems.

The Architectures of Zero-Recovery

  • PRP (Parallel Redundancy Protocol): A PRP node (like a controller or protective relay) has two independent network interfaces. It sends the same frame simultaneously over both networks (LAN A and LAN B). The destination node receives two identical frames and discards the duplicate. If one network fails, the frame from the other network arrives without any delay. Failure recovery time: 0ms.
  • HSR (High-availability Seamless Redundancy): HSR operates in a ring topology. Each node sends every frame in both directions on the ring. The destination node accepts the first arriving frame and discards the duplicate. Like PRP, it provides zero-time recovery from any single point of failure in the ring.

Fibre optics are the enabling physical medium for these architectures. Their high bandwidth, deterministic latency, and noise immunity make them ideal for building the redundant, long-distance rings required by PRP and HSR.

Vendors like Westermo and ATOP offer a range of switches and other devices designed specifically for these protocols, supporting dual-homed devices that eliminate single points of failure.

  • RSTP (Rapid Spanning Tree Protocol): For applications where sub-50ms to sub-200ms failover is acceptable, RSTP remains a cost-effective and widely supported option for creating redundant fibre ring topologies. It is less complex to implement than PRP/HSR but does not offer zero-recovery.

The choice of protocol depends on the criticality of the application. For the most demanding environments - power substation automation, safety systems, high-speed manufacturing - PRP and HSR are becoming the de facto standard.

Integrating Core Industrial Challenges

Bridging Legacy Fibre Systems with Modern IIoT and IT/OT Architectures

The Legacy Conundrum Pits Security Against Continuity

Many industrial sites contain a mix of modern Ethernet-based devices and legacy serial equipment (e.g., PLCs with RS-232/422/485, DH+, or Modbus RTU). These legacy systems often hold critical process data but represent a significant challenge for IIoT integration and security.

The solution lies in intelligent protocol gateways. Devices from suppliers like ProSoft Technology and ATOP act as secure bridges, translating between legacy serial protocols and modern TCP/IP, often with built-in firewall capabilities. Instead of a risky "rip-and-replace" strategy, these gateways allow for a phased modernization, enabling data from legacy controllers to be securely brought into IT/OT analytics platforms without compromising the stability or security of the original control loop.

Cybersecurity Matters

The Human Layer of Fibre Security: Procedures, Training, and the Cost of Complacency

Complacency Creates More Vulnerabilities Than Technology Gaps

The most advanced encryption and AI monitoring can be undone by a single human oversight. A technician plugging an untested laptop into a control network port, a contractor leaving a patch panel unlocked, or an engineer using default passwords on a new device - these actions create immediate and severe risks.

A robust fibre security strategy must include a continuous Human Factor programme:

  • Strict Procedures: Documented and enforced processes for network changes, physical access, and device commissioning.
  • Role-Based Training: Regular, practical training for engineers, technicians, and contractors on OT-specific cyber-risks.
  • A Culture of Security: Fostering an environment where every team member feels responsible for network integrity and is empowered to question and report suspicious activity.

Troubleshooting the “Three Killers”: Attenuation, Dispersion & BER in Complex Industrial Topologies

The Silent Degradation Often Goes Unnoticed Until Crisis

Fibre networks don't always fail catastrophically; they often degrade slowly. Understanding the "three killers" is essential for maintaining network health.

  1. Attenuation: The loss of optical power as light travels through the fibre. Caused by bends, poor splices, dirty connectors, or simply long distances. Solution: Use an Optical Power Meter and OTDR to measure loss, ensure clean connections, and verify link loss budgets during design.
  2. Dispersion: The spreading of a light pulse as it travels, which can cause inter-symbol interference at high data rates and over long distances. Solution: Choose the correct fibre type (e.g., single-mode for long distances) and ensure transceivers are matched to the fibre's dispersion characteristics.
  3. High Bit Error Rate (BER): The ratio of received errors to total bits sent. A high BER indicates a noisy, degraded link that can cause communication timeouts and data corruption. It is often the result of high attenuation, dispersion, or faulty transceivers. Solution: Use a BER tester, and systematically check for and eliminate the root causes of attenuation and dispersion.

Proactive, scheduled testing with the right tools is the only way to catch this silent degradation before it leads to a operational crisis.

Frequently Asked Questions - Answered

Here are just some answers to key questions.

Noise immunity ensures the signal's integrity, but it doesn't control its timing. Determinism (via TSN) manages when the signal arrives. In synchronized multi-axis robotics or power grid protection, a noise-free signal that arrives a millisecond late is just as useless as a corrupted one.

While complex, the threat is real for critical infrastructure. More importantly, the "inherently secure" myth leads to complacency in other areas, like unsecured media converters and patch panels. A holistic security strategy addresses both sophisticated and simple attack vectors.

An unmanaged converter is a transparent, dumb device. A managed converter can enforce security policies: it can be configured with VLANs to isolate traffic, have unused ports disabled, and provide logs of link status and data rates, offering visibility and control.

Modern AI monitoring systems from industrial vendors are designed to integrate via APIs or standard protocols like SNMP. They can feed alerts and health scores directly into your existing SCADA, Historian, or Network Operations Center (NOC) dashboard, providing context without requiring a separate silo of information.

It depends on your hardware. MACsec requires support in the network switches and, ideally, hardware acceleration. A network audit will determine if your current infrastructure can support it or if an upgrade to certified switches (e.g., from Westermo) is necessary.

Choose PRP (or HSR) when your control application cannot tolerate any packet loss during a failure event - common in power utility protection schemes and high-speed safety systems. If your system can handle a brief (sub-200ms) interruption, a Fibre Ring with RSTP is a more cost-effective solution.

Yes, securely. Using an industrial protocol gateway from a vendor like ProSoft or ATOP, you can translate the Modbus RTU traffic to Modbus TCP/IP or MQTT. The key is to use a gateway with a built-in firewall to filter traffic and to segment the legacy devices on their own VLAN.

Begin by measuring the Bit Error Rate (BER) on the affected links. A high BER is a key indicator of underlying physical problems. Then, use an OTDR to check for abnormal attenuation events (microbends, bad splices) and ensure all connectors are perfectly clean. This "silent degradation" is a classic symptom of the "three killers."

Your Next Step Towards a Deterministic, Secure & Resilient Operation

The principles outlined here - from deterministic timing and layered security to predictive monitoring and zero-recovery architectures - are not isolated technical features. They are the interconnected layers of a modern industrial fibre strategy. Addressing them requires a fundamental shift from viewing the network as passive cabling to treating it as an active, intelligent, and critical asset.

The knowledge, technology, and industrial-grade components from leading suppliers like Westermo, Welotec, ProSoft, and ATOP exist today to engineer this level of certainty. The time to move beyond legacy thinking and inherent assumptions is now.

Deepen Your Expertise with Our Smart Learning Hub

Mastering these concepts is an ongoing process. Subscribe to the Link & Layer | Smart Learning Hub to receive exclusive, in-depth content that breaks down each of these pillars. We provide the actionable insights, vendor-neutral guidance, and strategic frameworks you need to transform your industrial network from a source of risk into a foundation of competitive advantage.

Your Path to a Resilient Fibre Backbone Begins Here

The integrity of your industrial fibre network is not a niche technical concern; it is the bedrock of your operational resilience and cybersecurity posture. The journey from a vulnerable, forgotten backbone to a secure, monitored, and high-performance asset requires a deliberate strategy, blending physical-layer expertise with modern cybersecurity principles.

The insights in this guide provide the map, but the journey is yours to start. For a deeper dive into the technical specifics, our specialist team has developed a series of detailed implementation guides and configuration templates.

Subscribe to the Link & Layer | Smart Learning Hub to receive our exclusive "Industrial Fibre Hardening Checklist," a comprehensive asset register template, and detailed technical briefs on implementing MACsec and PRP in multi-vendor environments.

Don't let your most critical asset remain your greatest vulnerability. Contact a Throughput Technologies specialist today for a no-obligation assessment of your industrial network backbone.




You May Also Be Interested In ...

Industrial Fibre Optics Matters
Deterministic Networking: Beyond Bandwidth in OT

In industrial networks, determinism - not raw speed - ensures reliability. Predictable timing, low jitter, and synchronized control loops, supported by TSN and fibre optics, prevent safety incidents and maintain operational continuity.

Industrial Fibre Optics Matters
Industrial Fibre Security Myths: Beyond Tap-Proof

Fibre isn’t inherently secure; physical attacks, rogue transceivers, and insecure media converters threaten industrial networks. True protection requires controlled access, continuous monitoring, and trusted hardware with layered security measures.

Industrial Fibre Optics Matters
Industrial Network Vulnerabilities: Hidden Risks

Unmanaged media converters, patch panels, and switches silently expose industrial networks to attack. Simple, overlooked devices create hidden vulnerabilities - securing them with trusted hardware and monitoring transforms weak points into strong defences.